FAQ/Bayes - CBU statistics Wiki

Upload page content

You can upload content for the page named below. If you change the page name, you can also upload content for another page. If the page name is empty, we derive the page name from the file name.

File to load page content from
Page name
Comment
Finzd thee wrang lelters ino eacuh wosrd

location: FAQ / Bayes

How do I calculate and interpret conditional probabilities?

Gigerenzer (2002) suggests a way to obtain conditional probabilities using frequencies in a decision tree. An illustrated example (Wininger and Johnson, 2018) using this method in prosthetics is is here.

Cortina and Dunlap (1997) give an example evaluating the detection rate of a test (positive/negative result) to detect schizophrenia (disorder).

To do this one fixes the following:

The base rate of schizophrenia in adults (2%)

The test will correctly identify schizophrenia (give a positive result) on 95% of people with schizophrenia

The test will correctly identify normal individuals (give a negative result) on 97% of normal people.

Despite this we can show the test is unreliable.

This is a more intuitive way of illustrating the equivalent Bayesian equation:

$$\mbox{P(No disorder|+ result) = }\frac{\mbox{P(No disorder) * P(+ result | No disorder)}}{\mbox{P(No disorder) * P(+ result | No disorder) + P(Disorder) * P(- result | Disorder)}}$$

A talk with subtitles further illustrating aspects of conditional probabilities given by Ted Donnelly (Oxford), a geneticist, is available for viewing here.

Using statistical distributions of likelihoods and priors to obtain posterior distributions

Baguley (2012, p.393-395) gives formulae for the posterior mean ($$u_text{post}$$) and variance ($$\sigma_text{post}^text{2}$$)

for a normal distribution, of form

N(u, sigma2 ), with an assumed prior distribution of form N(u_p, sigma_p2 ) and an obtained likelihood distribution (obtained using sample data) equal to a N(u_lik, sigma_lik2 ). In particular

sigma_post2 = [ 1 /sigma_lik2 + 1 /sigma_p2 ] -1

  • u_post = (sigma_post2 / sigma_lik2 ) u_lik + (sigma_post2 / sigma_p2 ) u_p

Zoltan Dienes also has a comprehensive website featuring a range of on-line Bayesian calculators including one that will evaluate posterior means and sds for Normal distributions here.

Baguley also gives references for obtaining posterior distributions for data having a binomial distribution which assumes a beta distribution as its prior distribution. For this reason the posterior distribution, in this case, is called a beta-binomial distribution.

WINBUGS is freeware for fitting a range of models using simulation (via the Gibbs sampler) and is available from here.

References

Andrews M and Baguley T (2013) Prior approval: The growth of Bayesian methods in psychology British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 66(1) 1–7. Primer article free on-line to CBSU users.

Baguley T (2012) Serious Stats. A guide to advanced statistics for the behavioral sciences. Palgrave Macmillan:New York.

Cortina JM, Dunlap WP (1997) On the logic and purpose of significance testing. Psychological Methods 2(2) 161-172.

Gelman A and Shalizi CR (2013) Philosophy and the practice of Bayesian statistics British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 66(1) 8–38. Primer article free to access on-line to CBSU users.

Gigerenzer G (2002) Reckoning with risk: learning to live with uncertainty. London: Penguin.

Krushchk JK (2011) Doing bayesian data analysis: a tutorial using R and BUGS. Academic Press:Elsevier. For further reading: genuinely accessible to beginners illustrating using prior and posterior probabilities in inference for ANOVAs and other regression models.

Wininger M and Johnson R (2018) Prosthetic hand signals:how Bayesian inference can decode movement intentions and control the next generation of powered prostheses. Significance 15(4) 30-35.