<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><!DOCTYPE article  PUBLIC '-//OASIS//DTD DocBook XML V4.4//EN'  'http://www.docbook.org/xml/4.4/docbookx.dtd'><article><articleinfo><title>FAQ/Bayes</title><revhistory><revision><revnumber>51</revnumber><date>2018-08-20 09:42:10</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>50</revnumber><date>2018-08-20 09:40:44</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>49</revnumber><date>2018-08-20 09:37:47</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>48</revnumber><date>2015-03-11 11:56:16</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>47</revnumber><date>2014-08-11 15:01:35</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>46</revnumber><date>2014-08-11 15:01:23</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>45</revnumber><date>2014-08-11 15:00:57</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>44</revnumber><date>2014-08-11 14:56:09</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>43</revnumber><date>2013-09-30 14:34:09</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>42</revnumber><date>2013-05-15 11:37:23</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>41</revnumber><date>2013-05-15 11:37:05</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>40</revnumber><date>2013-05-15 11:36:48</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>39</revnumber><date>2013-05-15 11:36:23</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>38</revnumber><date>2013-05-15 11:33:15</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>37</revnumber><date>2013-05-14 15:22:23</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>36</revnumber><date>2013-05-13 15:05:51</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>35</revnumber><date>2013-05-13 15:02:25</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>34</revnumber><date>2013-05-13 14:58:41</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>33</revnumber><date>2013-03-08 10:17:23</date><authorinitials>localhost</authorinitials><revremark>converted to 1.6 markup</revremark></revision><revision><revnumber>32</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:34:45</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>31</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:33:54</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>30</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:33:34</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>29</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:32:06</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>28</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:31:47</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>27</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:30:53</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>26</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:30:31</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>25</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:23:55</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>24</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 10:18:34</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>23</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 09:20:55</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>22</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 09:19:54</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>21</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 09:19:27</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>20</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 09:18:35</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>19</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 09:15:33</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>18</revnumber><date>2012-08-10 09:14:29</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>17</revnumber><date>2012-04-26 14:04:35</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>16</revnumber><date>2012-04-26 14:04:17</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>15</revnumber><date>2011-04-19 12:47:03</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>14</revnumber><date>2011-04-19 12:46:15</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>13</revnumber><date>2011-04-19 12:08:07</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>12</revnumber><date>2009-11-23 12:12:31</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>11</revnumber><date>2009-11-23 12:11:49</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>10</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 16:16:29</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>9</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 16:15:33</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>8</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 16:15:15</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>7</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 16:14:22</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>6</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 16:14:06</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>5</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 16:10:14</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>4</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 15:54:11</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>3</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 15:50:17</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>2</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 15:50:04</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision><revision><revnumber>1</revnumber><date>2007-08-13 15:41:10</date><authorinitials>PeterWatson</authorinitials></revision></revhistory></articleinfo><section><title>How do I calculate and interpret conditional probabilities?</title><para>Gigerenzer (2002) suggests a way to obtain conditional probabilities using frequencies in a decision tree. An illustrated example (Wininger and Johnson, 2018) using this method in prosthetics is <ulink url="https://imaging.mrc-cbu.cam.ac.uk/statswiki/FAQ/Bayes/statswiki/FAQ/Bayes?action=AttachFile&amp;do=get&amp;target=cond_prob.pdf">is here</ulink>. </para><para>Cortina and Dunlap (1997) give an example evaluating the detection rate of a test (positive/negative result) to detect schizophrenia (disorder). </para><para>To do this one fixes the following: </para><para>The base rate of schizophrenia in adults (2%) </para><para>The test will correctly identify schizophrenia (give a positive result) on 95% of people with schizophrenia </para><para>The test will correctly identify normal individuals (give a negative result) on 97% of normal people.  </para><para>Despite this we can show the <ulink url="https://imaging.mrc-cbu.cam.ac.uk/statswiki/FAQ/Bayes/statswiki/FAQ/Bayes?action=AttachFile&amp;do=get&amp;target=bayes.doc">test is unreliable</ulink>. </para><para>This is a more intuitive way of illustrating the equivalent Bayesian equation: </para><para>$$\mbox{P(No disorder|+ result) = }\frac{\mbox{P(No disorder) * P(+ result | No disorder)}}{\mbox{P(No disorder) * P(+ result | No disorder) + P(Disorder) * P(- result | Disorder)}}$$ </para><para>A talk with subtitles further illustrating aspects of conditional probabilities given by Ted Donnelly (Oxford), a geneticist, is available for viewing <ulink url="http://blog.ted.com/2006/11/statistician_pe.php">here.</ulink> </para><itemizedlist><listitem><para><ulink url="https://imaging.mrc-cbu.cam.ac.uk/statswiki/FAQ/Bayes/statswiki/FAQ/Bayes?action=AttachFile&amp;do=get&amp;target=bayes2.doc">More on Bayes theorem:Illustration of priors and likelihoods</ulink> </para></listitem></itemizedlist><para><emphasis role="underline">Using statistical distributions of likelihoods and priors to obtain posterior distributions</emphasis> </para><para>Baguley (2012, p.393-395) gives formulae for the posterior mean ($$u_text{post}$$) and variance ($$\sigma_text{post}^text{2}$$)  </para><para>for a normal distribution, of form  </para><para>N(u, sigma<superscript>2 </superscript>),  with an assumed prior distribution of form  N(u_p, sigma_p<superscript>2 </superscript>) and an obtained likelihood distribution (obtained using sample data) equal to a  N(u_lik, sigma_lik<superscript>2 </superscript>). In particular </para><para>sigma_post<superscript>2 </superscript> =  [ 1 /sigma_lik<superscript>2 </superscript> + 1 /sigma_p<superscript>2</superscript> ] <superscript>-1</superscript> </para><itemizedlist><listitem override="none"><para>u_post = (sigma_post<superscript>2</superscript> / sigma_lik<superscript>2</superscript> ) u_lik + (sigma_post<superscript>2 </superscript> /  sigma_p<superscript>2 </superscript>) u_p  </para></listitem></itemizedlist><para>Zoltan Dienes also has a comprehensive website featuring a range of on-line Bayesian calculators including one that will evaluate posterior means and sds for Normal distributions <ulink url="http://www.lifesci.sussex.ac.uk/home/Zoltan_Dienes/inference/Bayes.htm">here.</ulink> </para><para>Baguley also gives references for obtaining posterior distributions for data having a binomial distribution which assumes a beta distribution as its prior distribution. For this reason the posterior distribution, in this case, is called a beta-binomial distribution. </para><para>WINBUGS is freeware for fitting a range of models using simulation (via the Gibbs sampler) and is available from <ulink url="http://www.mrc-bsu.cam.ac.uk/bugs/winbugs/contents.shtml">here.</ulink> </para><itemizedlist><listitem><para><ulink url="http://rsos.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/1/3/140216">Using conditional probabilities to compute False Discovery Rates (article)</ulink> </para></listitem></itemizedlist><para><emphasis role="underline">References</emphasis> </para><para>Andrews M and Baguley T (2013) Prior approval: The growth of Bayesian methods in psychology <emphasis>British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical  Psychology</emphasis> <emphasis role="strong">66(1)</emphasis> 1–7. Primer article free on-line to CBSU users. </para><para>Baguley T (2012) Serious Stats. A guide to advanced statistics for the behavioral sciences. Palgrave Macmillan:New York. </para><para>Cortina JM, Dunlap WP (1997) On the logic and purpose of significance testing. <emphasis>Psychological Methods</emphasis> <emphasis role="strong">2(2)</emphasis> 161-172. </para><para>Gelman A and Shalizi CR (2013) Philosophy and the practice of Bayesian statistics <emphasis>British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology</emphasis> <emphasis role="strong">66(1)</emphasis> 8–38. Primer article free to access on-line to CBSU users. </para><para>Gigerenzer G (2002) Reckoning with risk: learning to live with uncertainty. London: Penguin. </para><para>Krushchk JK (2011) Doing bayesian data analysis: a tutorial using R and BUGS. Academic Press:Elsevier. For further reading: genuinely accessible to beginners illustrating using prior and posterior probabilities in inference for ANOVAs and other regression models. </para><para>Wininger M and Johnson R (2018) Prosthetic hand signals:how Bayesian inference can decode movement intentions and control the next generation of powered prostheses. <emphasis>Significance</emphasis> <emphasis role="strong">15(4)</emphasis> 30-35. </para></section></article>